Senators Thune and Vitter Will Oppose Kagan Confirmation

The latest two United States Senators announcing their intention to vote against the nomination of Elena Kagan to the United States Supreme Court are Senator John Thune from South Dakota and Senator David Vitter from Louisiana. It is hard to believe that there has ever been a more left-leaning Supreme Court nominee than Elena Kagan.

----------

Senator Thune:

WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Senator John Thune today made the following statement regarding Elena Kagan's nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court:

"After meeting with Solicitor General Kagan and after careful deliberation, I cannot support her confirmation to the Supreme Court. While Ms. Kagan's background in academia is impressive, I have deep reservations about her ability to serve on the nation's highest court with impartiality.

"Ms. Kagan's lack of judicial and courtroom experience, combined with her partisan political background, leads me to question her ability to separate her personal political beliefs from her duty of objectivity while on the bench. While judicial experience is not a prerequisite for serving on the Supreme Court, a record of impartiality throughout a career is an important factor to consider, especially when concerns are raised about a nominee's partisan past.

"Throughout her career, Ms. Kagan has shown a strong commitment to a far left ideological belief system. We have only her word-and nothing else-to indicate that she will apply the law to the facts, and not her ideology to the law. For these reasons, I do not believe Ms. Kagan meets the standard to serve on the Supreme Court, and I cannot support her confirmation."

Senator Vitter:

"I'm going to vote against Solicitor General Kagan to be our next Supreme Court Justice. I believe we must have justices in our highest court who respect a strict constructionist interpretation of our Constitution, but her track record leaves me to believe that Solicitor General Kagan will legislate from the bench. When I met with her in June, the meeting brought up clear concerns about her past legal work - specifically related to her views on Second Amendment rights, reasonable protections for life, and military recruiters on campus. Unfortunately, none of my concerns were alleviated during her Senate confirmation hearings so I will oppose her nomination," said Vitter.

Syndicate content